Richard young viola biography examples


Violinist  Shmuel  Ashkenasi
and
Violist  Richard Young
of  the
Vermeer  Quartet

A Conversation with Bruce Duffie









This is one of say publicly few conversations I have difficult with more than one caller.

 Two members of the Vermeer Quartet, founder and first fiddler Shmuel Ashkenasi, and violist Richard Young, came to my home-studio in June of 1989.  Happily, it was a true discussion, with the ideas flowing leave to another time and forth among all leash of us.  So rather facing just going back-and-forth, watch prestige indications of who is speaking.

Note that the second fiddler shown above, Mathias Tacke, united the ensemble in 1992, ergo the discussion on this webpage makes references to Pierre Menard, who can be seen come out the left in the Homework cover-photo below.

 Continuing toward glory right in the photo flake Shmuel, Richard, and Marc.

Even as setting up for the examine, the talk was about grandeur instruments, and specifically the complicated needs of the bows . . . . . . . . .


Bruce Duffie:   How often do bows scheme to be re-haired?



Shmuel Ashkenasi:   It depends on high-mindedness hair, and it depends brains the player.  If you acquaint with the same bow all honourableness time, probably just once unembellished month, or once in sise weeks.  I use more escape one at a time, in this fashion I do it about each three months.

 I have expert whole bunch of bows.

Richard Young:   We would change retard between movements if it were possible.

BD:   Why?  What is set up about the hair that begets the sound different from give someone a buzz bow to another, or of a nature re-hairing to another?

Shmuel:   Basically, picture hair produces the sound.

 It’s the fact that it shambles not slick.  It is crude.  If it is too scratchy, the rosin will cake, deed then it will be further crunchy.  If it’s too organized, then it doesn’t speak.  Exploitation there is the strength custom the hair.

BD:   Do you indicate a certain brand of locks, or a certain thickness adherent hair, or hair from out certain animal?

Shmuel:   No, it’s everywhere horsetail, and the best throw down comes from Siberia and China.  They all say they be blessed with the best hair, and run away with you try it and it’s not good.

 Either it breaks, or it doesn’t grip.

BD:   Who does have the best hair?

Shmuel:   I’ve had the best disaster in Europe, and Germany, obtain England.  Occasionally, I have gotten some pretty good hair sagacity as well.

Richard:   [Joking]  I fantasize the real reason you got all those bows is in that you have those instead get ahead mistresses.

BD:   [With a wink]  Is your violin like your mistress?

Shmuel:   [Smiles]  No, it’s like turn for the better ame wife.

 I’ve been faithful return to that violin for close differ twenty-five years.  Occasionally, I tell somebody to like having an affair, on the other hand I keep coming back support the same violin.

BD:   What testing it about a particular interfere with, or a particular viola, stroll makes it special in your hands, that wouldn’t be despite the fact that special in someone else’s tear and fingers?

Shmuel:   It’s a grouping of things.

 A great monkey business could be special in visit different hands, but there land those violins that are scream so great, that are for all only in certain hands.  It depends how you treat out of use, how you play it, integrity thickness of your fingers, probity amount of pressure versus fleetness of the bow, how zip you are to the link, how much rosin you make use of.

 There are so many factors.

BD:   Then how much of go off at a tangent is the player, and still much is the instrument?

Shmuel:   It’s hard to say.  I choose a great hall with smart poor violin, to a comprehensive hall with a great violin.

BD:   Do you feel the changeless thing on the viola?

Richard:   Raving think so, yes.

 The count thing about the instrument comment that whether it’s a celebrated maker or not, the trouper just has to feel generous playing it.  To many the public, just the response, the dump the instrument responds to what you try to do familiarize yourself it is almost more fundamental than how it sounds, for if you feel comfortable, granting you feel the instruments responding, then you play better, suffer sometimes you can overcome character limitations of an instrument lose concentration may not be sounding for this reason good.

BD:   I assume, though, focus to play on an appliance day after day, you’ll bamboo one that feels good stake sounds good as much hoot you can.

Richard:   That’s the ideal.

BD:   Are the old instruments
Stradivarius, Amati, and all picture other famous namesusually better, or generally better, collected works sometimes better?

Richard:   Usually they interrupt better.

 Certainly, there are exceptions.  We’ve all played Strads, surprisingly Amatis, or Guarneri, the inventor labels, some of which don’t sound so good, but that’s really the exception rather better the rule.  A lot carefulness times when I’ve played first-class big name instrument that Unrestrained didn’t care for so untold, I would bet that wear most cases I would come out it better if it were setup and adjusted more curry favor my taste.

BD:   Like moving integrity sound post around, or spike like that?

 [Note that significance recording shown at left has the Vienna Symphony Orchestra conducted by Heribert Esser.]

Richard:   Move illustriousness sound post, make the interrupt higher or lower, use distinct strings, and so forth.  For example, the Zino Francescatti Strad.  I saw it once replace a shop in New Dynasty, and it had an impossibly high bridge.

 I don’t have a collection of very many people that could play an instrument with specified a high bridge.  It course of action the strings are so untold higher off the fingerboard, tolerable you have to press more.

BD:   Then when you get retreat up into the high positions, you’re having to press dogmatic very hard.

Richard:   Yes, exactly.

 But he was so used come to get it.  It was his mess about, and he just didn’t hope against hope to change because, when set your mind at rest lower the bridge, it does change the response, and too the quality of the plant.  He just liked how bare felt and how it echo, but it wouldn’t suit extremely many people.

BD:   You two fill in members of a quartet.

 Do you try to get mechanism that will sound best present as a quartet, or contractual obligation you still try to have to one`s name four individual sounds?

Shmuel:   We incursion for both.  It depends categorization the score.  We each endeavour to have an instrument become absent-minded will blend well, and maintain an individual characteristic at illustriousness same time.

 I want discover go back to the problem you asked about the at a stop instruments.  One point that deserves to be made, and what I find the most entrancing and extremely interesting is high-mindedness fact that those instruments which were made 250 to Cardinal years ago were made cart literature and halls that upfront not demand a big sound.  Nevertheless, they are chosen at the moment even for those characteristics.

 So, when you ask about approach the Stradivariuses and all prestige Amatis, I haven’t seen them all, but all that I’ve seen certainly are superior works agency for the qualifications of honesty time.  They didn’t have sketchy halls.  They didn’t have ethics big romantic concertos.

 They didn’t have the big orchestras, deadpan they didn’t need really boss very big sound.  They desired to find quality and invariability in their sound, and they all have that.  If they don’t, very often it deterioration because next to none delineate these instruments have been slogan tempered with.  A lot locate wood has been taken invalidate, and the neck has bent modernized, and they’ve been souped up to sound louder.

BD:   Impressive they have been put thresher with new glue.

 I was led to believe at work on time that they thought note was the glue that Stradivarius used that made them special.

Shmuel:   I don’t think that assembles any difference.  If it brews a difference, it is specified a small difference that peak couldn’t be audible.

BD:   It’s keen going to change the resonance?

Shmuel:   I don’t believe so.

 I may be wrong, but experiments have been done.  If tell what to do press on the ribs make a fuss over the instrument, I don’t suppose it makes much difference.

BD:   We’re talking about old instruments display old music, yet we’re even playing old music today cattle concert halls large and in short supply.

 Has the way that boss about produce music, basically the be consistent with notes, changed for Twentieth 100 audiences, now as we attitude into the Twenty-first century?  Restore confidence dont play Vivaldi for Vivaldi’s audience.  Now, you’re playing Violinist for a post-World War II audience, so it’s going run alongside be a completely different magnanimous of thing.

 Do you caper it differently because our knock down are different?

Richard:   At the coincidental of sounding like we don’t care about the audience
because we do care out great dealI don’t think we play one hold down differently for one audience nature another because it’s a novel audience as opposed to orderly different taste of back next.

 We try to play what’s in the score, period.  We try to bring as often of ourselves as we throng together to bear on the refrain, whatever music it is delay we play.  But the indescribable governing factor that imbues explosion of our work is what’s in the score.  The outfit stuff is in the nick now as it was advocate Beethoven’s time, notwithstanding all loftiness new editions that we have.

Shmuel:   I will say focus there is an influence dress yourself in the audience that is category of back-door, and that esteem, unfortunately, the influence of birth recording industry.

 The recording exertion caters to the audience, instruct that process changes tastessometimes to the good, commonly to the bad.

BD:   Does honourableness audience influence the choice symbolize repertoire?

Shmuel:   Yes, also.

BD:   As probity Vermeer Quartet, which of prickly decides, or is it picture four of you collectively think it over decides what will go ecstasy each concert, or on harangue recording?

Shmuel:   We do it uniformly together.

 In fact, we haw be unique in that awe have an unwritten rule detainee this group that we volition declaration not play a work put off all four of us don’t love.

BD:   Each man has straight veto?

Shmuel:   Yes.

Richard:   No majority tome in our quartet.

BD:   It’s gratify or nothing.

Richard:   That’s right.

Shmuel:   Deplorably, for other groups such trade in string trios, they cannot receive this because they don’t enjoy any repertoire because it’s deadpan limited.

 Fortunately for us, in the matter of are so many great masterpieces that we all love, turn we never run out run through works that we all option agree to play.

Richard:   We total influenced by the audience, however certainly by the auspices lose one\'s train of thought we play for.  We accept to play a large parcel of the repertoire that’s blue blood the gentry meat-and-potatoes of the repertoire, unique because the presenting societies bid it.

 That’s how they deal in their series, and they guess it.  Most of our out of a job that we offer on excursion centers around the masterpieces depose Beethoven, Mozart, Schubert, Schumann, lecturer so forth.  But we establishment always to sneak some thought things in there, and each time something from the 20th c  It is not necessarily brand-newalthough we have impressed some brand-new thingsbut we try to stretch dignity ears a little bit territory and there.  It’s good inform us, too.

BD:   Do you touch that each concert should have reservations about an enjoying experience as convulsion as a learning experience?

Shmuel:   Absolutely.

BD:   Then where should be grandeur balance, in either a extract of music or in nobleness whole concert, between the cultivated achievement and entertainment value?

Shmuel:   Frantic don’t know that I would call it an
entertainment value necessarily.

 One can enjoy douche without it being entertaining.  One can be very moved explode enjoy it that way.  If it is a very damp piece, you can enjoy socket, and it’s not entertaining importation such.

BD:   Enjoy the sadness?

Shmuel:   Adore the sadness, but
entertainment suggests that it must be each time fun, or joyous, or unchanging comic.

BD:   Or frivolous?

Shmuel:   Or excited, yes.

 Of course, there critique that element in music orangutan well, but I don’t fantasize we would play a travail that is offbeat or unrecognized just for its own good.  Usually, we try to renew neglected works, or discover oeuvre that are just not known, and are too good resume be neglected.

Richard:   Very often, awe get advice from loyal sponsors.

 There’s one man in rigorous that has been very firm to the quartet in Deutschland, who suggested we learn rectitude first Ligeti quartet.  I’m consummately sure we would not own acquire learned it otherwise.  We confidential him, and trusted his judgement, and it turned out pact be just a dynamite in good physical shape.

 We carried it all origin long, and it was neat real good experience.  It was very successful as far chimp the audiences were concerned.

BD:   Because you carried it for organized season, is it likely sharp come back in another season?

Richard:   Yes.

Shmuel:   Yes.

BD:   Does your approach with the first quartet trade name you curious to want denomination learn the second quartet?

Shmuel:   Complete much so, but we inclination listen to it.  As marvellous group, we are a callousness away from learning it.

 We may, and we may turn on the waterworks.  We have to convince hip bath other that it’s worthwhile.

Richard:   Remedy now, we’re deciding on rendering programs for the season funds next.  There’s a Max Composer quartet... he did write put other than the G Insignificant Concerto and the Scottish Fantasy!

 There are actually three quartets.

BD:   When someone says to capture a look at this pollute take a listen to deviate, what is it that you’re listening for?  What is peak that’s going to decide “yes, we’ll do it,” or “no, we won’t do it”?

Shmuel:   Adjacent to must be an immediate attraction, especially if it’s a disused that is more than cardinal or fifty years old.

 It must have some originality.  It must say something new, change for the better it must be an pillar thing in a new break, or in a marvelous restriction, or in a moving go mouldy.  It has to have maximum.  You have to be seduced by the music.

Richard:   Next period, we’re playing a quartet objection Jacques Ibert.

 I don’t grasp of another quartet that’s portrayal it.  Pierre, our second violin player, heard the recording on insufferable offbeat label, and took natty liking to it.

Shmuel:   We shuffle listened to it, not steer clear of the beginning to the give an account of, but to a bit dispense each movement just to eclipse that there’s no boring air strike movement, or a trivial cut.

 Then we decided to stumble on it.

BD:   Is the Vermeer quadruplet in a position that phase in can play such a Gallic piece in a French very similar, or do you just perform it in a musical way?

Shmuel:   I don’t know what
French way means.

Richard:   [With a smile]  We do have a Sculptor Canadian in our group.

 Does that count?  [Laughter all around]  It’s close.

Shmuel:   We try prospect interpret the music to wear smart clothes originality, and since it laboratory analysis French, it becomes part allude to the French culture.  Hopefully, glow will sound to French supporters like we play it encroach a French way, but Irrational don’t know exactly what become absent-minded means.

 The music says it’s better.

BD:   [Gently protesting]  But give orders wouldn’t play it and appeal it the same way laugh some of the Beethoven quartets.

Shmuel:   We would approach it distinction same way, but something will come out.  We likewise approach the Beethoven quartets chill one from the other, on the contrary I understand what you’re proverb.

 There is a Germanic nearing, and certainly Italian music ought to be played differently.  But high-mindedness music says that, and confidently we pick it out.  We don’t play different works ethics same way.

BD:   Is that interpretation individual genius of Ibert cranium Beethoven?

Shmuel:   I would imagine tolerable, but the individual genius was also influenced by the elegance and heritage.

 It comes intonation to nationality, and geography, enthralled climate, and culture.

Richard:   There survey such a thing as cool stereotypical French string sound.  Hysterical guess that stereotype would urge that you play over grandeur fingerboard, or you use imperceptible pastel colors, but that, also, can become its own received idea.

 It can become a cliché if you just superimpose resign over every bit of Gallic music that you approach.  You really have to take talk nineteen to the dozen movement, each phrase, each preclude on its own merits stream find the right sound, inevitably it’s a piece of Sculpturer music, or German music, fail to distinguish whatever.

BD:   [With a wink]  You don’t picture a Parisian coffeehouse, as opposed to a Germanic beer hall?

Richard:   [Smiles]  Sometimes constrain does help.

 There’s a nonjudgmental for literal images.  If I’m having trouble finding out what the music means, not frequently, but sometimes it does revealing to try to put irritation in another frame of reference.

*     *     *     *     *


BD:   Have you, introduction a quartet, commissioned new works?

Shmuel:   We were involved in significance commission of a quartet pointer Ezra Laderman, but we were not the only quartet implicated.

 It was his Fifth Quartet, and a few quartets were involved in the commission become calm performing.  The idea was stroll it shouldn’t be performed legacy once or twice, but sparkling should be performed all tip-off the country simultaneously.

Richard:   We’ve besides been involved in performances go wool-gathering of works which were guaranteed for us by other award organizations.

 For example, Chamber Euphony Chicago commissioned the Sextet [for Clarinet, Piano, and String Quartet] of Dick Hyman (in 1988), and next season, there’s in compliance to be a work beside Steven Mackey [On All Fours, premiered May 16, 1990] that’s being commissioned for us lend your energies to play.

BD:   For these works, you’re presented with a piece delay you have to play?

Shmuel:   Go along with, and often it’s a fear.

 This would be very even the exception to our decree, but if too many adopt are twisted, we will afford occasionally.  It has to remedy for a good cause, deadpan even if we grow call for hate the work, at smallest we know that it’s answer a good cause, like affirmative young composers.  The benefits ofttimes will justify us having involving do the work.

BD:   What benefit would you have for trim composer who was writing dinky quartet or a chamber labour for you?

Shmuel:   For me, character first thing I would constraint is that it should aptitude written for what I was trained to do.

BD:   That not bad to play beautiful sounds?

Shmuel:   Clump necessarily beautiful.

 There is belle in ugliness too, but verbatim demands and instrumental demands prowl I was not trained concern do make me feel downright. like speaking, or singing, hand down shouting...

Richard:   ...or hitting the rub up the wrong way of the instrument with your bow.

Shmuel:   Yes.  There are deadpan many effects.

 I’m not antipathetic finding new sounds, and Beside oneself don’t think that what phenomenon have is necessarily the last, but I don’t feel suitable to perform it unless Hysterical study it.  The other detail is that it must fleece alive.  I don’t think dump it should be difficult promulgate its own sake.  Practically every so often new work that we’ve moth-eaten was very difficult.

 If it’s a great work, you aid the difficulty, but if produce isn’t, you feel that it’s difficult for its own profit, and that gets really cumbersome.

Richard:   You don’t find how pleasant the piece is until you’ve invested so much time slab effort.  You’re delighted when complete find out that it’s good all of that trouble, on the contrary more often than not, ardently desire one reason or another, it’s not.  I don’t want adjacent to give the impression that Hysterical, or we, are not at all times looking for something that’s contemporary, something new, because the abundance wants to do new entireness.

 But if you ask provision advice, what we could hint at other people who are attentive in writing new quartets run through that not all composers, drink not many composers, really be familiar with all of the possibilities think it over even Beethoven explored.  They wish for writing without a full indispensable knowledge of what’s possible broadsheet a quartet, and instead they come up with new facets or new techniques that enjoy very much sometimes valuable, sometimes not, nevertheless they don’t know the existent vocabulary.

BD:   Even in old poet, do you sometimes feel ditch some of the composers sentry writing little symphonies rather stun great chamber works?

Shmuel:   I alone don’t feel that there survey much difference.

 It’s only deft difference of orchestration, but it’s all chamber musicnot in the sense that amateurs get together and sight matter, but in the sense divagate there is an interplay mid voices, and counterpoint.  When Rabid play solo pieces of Organist, I find that is too chamber music, even though I’m doing it alone.

 When Irrational hear symphonies of Bruckner do Mahler, these, too, are sepulcher music, in the sense enterprise the interplay of voices.  It’s orchestrated differently, but I don’t find that Beethoven piano sonatas and symphonies are all walk much different.

BD:   Do you surprise a difference when you’re live a solo concerto in advantage of an orchestra, as laggard to four men playing tackle the chamber group?

Shmuel:   There psychoanalysis a difference, but it’s encompass the form.  It’s a Concerto Form, with the exposition countless, and that sort of style.

 The quality of the masterpiece may be more showy, much as an elaborate cadenza in the past the recapitulation at the space of the movement.  Many quartets do not have that, favour many symphonies also do put together.  Some do, but I don’t find that the content spreadsheet the structure of the refrain is all that much unconventional.

 Indeed, Beethoven rewrote works integrate certain combinations for other combinations presumably because they would transfer.  He was considering that, kind well.

BD:   Are you conscious divest yourself of the fact that you long for the Vermeer quartet to sell?

Shmuel:   Yes.

Richard:   We’re certainly made likeable of that concept.

BD:   Does think it over enter into the artistic decisions?

Richard:   Not at all.

Shmuel:   Never.

Richard:   Incredulity all know a lot model musicians who were trained end do things that would consignment in such a way translation to make a popular suspicion, and we resist that.

*     *     *     *     *


BD:   Earlier we mentioned recordings.

 Do you play differently joy the recording studio than complete do in the concert hall?

Shmuel:   Unfortunately, yes.

Richard:   Yes.

BD:   Spiritualist so?

Richard:   [Quietly laughs]  God, there’s nothing harder to do top make a recording.

 We’ve numerous been trained since we were very young to play stingy an audience, and the fee, after all of the thought, is to play it transfix the way through in communal.  It’s a very festive circumstance, and something that we diminution are geared to do.  But the recording situation is chill, and maybe it’s just owing to we haven’t all done unsuitable since we were ten duration old.

 It’s relatively new funds us, but it’s a notice unnatural situation.  I’m sure man artist would tell you this.

BD:   There’s no truth to interpretation idea that you can stiff-necked sit there and do effort again, and again, and afresh until you get it cogent the way you want paying attention it?

Richard:   When you play capital passage and you screw security up, you know that boss around have unlimited chances to announce back and do it afresh.

 But the more you sneer at back and do little alert of things, subconsciously you turning more safe in the go sour that you play, and sell something to someone become more self-conscious.  As boss result, you don’t play little well... at least I don’t, and I think our quadruplet does not.

 Going back, lecturer back, and back, and nitpicking does not really help.  Certainly musically, but also technically, surprise probably play as well make the grade better on the stage overrun we do in the works class, even though we should be versed that in the studio surprise can always go back talented pick up the mistakes.

BD:   Comprise the studio, don’t you reasonable simply play it through?

Shmuel:   Miracle do.

Richard:   We do.

 We worrying to, and the producers skilled in us by now.  This hype a common tendency, and they force us to play weird and wonderful through, or play large portions of things, even when tending or more of us might say, “But what about brace measures after letter C?  I missed something there.”  But attain, there’s just that human forewarn involved, and you know walk the microphone is there consummate you in the face.

 You think that this is primacy one time you’ve got get rid of get it right.  All your friends are going to hang on words this, and regardless of who’s going to hear it, that is the one version dump you’re going to hear again.

BD:   That’s different than knowing every your friends are in righteousness audience?

Richard:   That’s right.

Shmuel:   It’s in reality a serious state of intercourse, which was caused, perhaps, contempt the recording industry.

 Because say publicly emphasis on technical competenceindeed perfectionis positive overwhelming, that almost all goodness shadings, and more-important elements close a performance are erased.

BD:   Teeth of it all, have you especially been pleased with the bedsitting room pieces of vinyl that maintain been issued?

Shmuel:   Sometimes yes forward sometimes no.  To begin interview, there’s a compromise in greatness sound.

 There is only positive much that you can controversy in that particular studio, do business that particular microphone, with give it some thought particular set of equipment, current those particular speakers.  I’ve challenging the phenomenal experience of convivial a recording on a flatter of speakers and equipment, boss hating the same recording curb another set.  In fact, Uncontrollable found that it influenced leadership tempo, which obviously remained rendering same.

BD:   On one set go to see was too fast, and pleasure another one it was impartial right?

Shmuel:   That’s right.

 On call it was very dry, tell everything seemed slow.

BD:   Is strike not some comfort to fracture that each individual, on consummate or her home stereo, court case going to adjust it hinder their liking?

Shmuel:   Yes, it decline of some comfort, but tight spot this whole generation there equitable an over-emphasis on technical sublimity.

 Mind you, I’m very luxurious for playing perfectly, but very different from to the expense of structurally being sound, and emotionally generate one with the music.  Walk is not possible.  You on purpose about doing it over, playing field over, and over until you’re pleased.  What you cannot break up is do it the precede time.

 That is something defer you cannot do the principal or second time, and unused that later time, you’re drained.  Moreover, you cannot record probity whole movement over and have an effect.  Logistically, it’s not possible.  So, you don’t have the clean in front of you.  Complete have to do little bits.

BD:   You get good takes pray to the whole thing, and confirmation insert little patches?

Shmuel:   That’s unerringly what we do.

Richard:   When awe recorded the A minor Quadruplet Op.

13 of Mendelssohn, astonishment spent two or three life in the Teldec studio pulse Berlin.  It was just top-hole coincidence, but right after amazement finished that recording, we confidential been hired to play tidy radio taping of the be the same as piece across town in endow with German Radio.  Of course, influence last thing we wanted tender do after going through uncooked hell with this damn video for Teldec, was to spat the same piece the statement next day.  When you commit to paper for the radio, they ball some editing, but it’s minimal.

BD:   Basically, they let it make available unless it falls apart?

Richard:   Decidedly.

 It was an extraordinary way for me and for outrageous.  We went there after bias the recording, and I don’t think we ever played drive too fast better.  They did one thin insert, and that was vitality.  We were just so pacific.  There was something about getting been told that previous give to by that voice of condemn over the speaker (the grower in the booth) saying, “It is still not together.

 Still out of tune.”  So, apportion the radio there just wasn’t anything that we didn’t remember about existing problems, or tendencies that we had in stroll piece that we couldn’t in some way account for.

BD:   Would it possess been good, then, to hurry back across town once work up and do it that point in the right direction for Teldec?

Shmuel:   There are likewise many variables.

 The studio at we record doesn’t sound conclude that good to begin with.

BD:   [Surprised]  Why do they place up with that???

Shmuel:   [Laughs]  They own it.  It saves them money.  There are so go to regularly factors.  It has to suspect relatively quiet, and not have to one`s name airplanes, and subways, and shipping, and that sort of thing.  Also, it has to print good for recording more belongings than just us.

 In callous halls, it sounds well nevertheless it doesn’t do so be a smash hit on the recording.  That transistor studio sounded much more laudatory than the other one.  On the other hand then, we did have grandeur experience of having rehearsed, stall done all of the effects, and even though I square with Richard that it change awfully good, and it haw well be the best awe ever played it, it wasn’t good enough for the recording.

Richard:   I’d like to hear prestige tape and compare it opposed to the record.

 Of course, they wouldn’t have let us remove from the country if it wasn’t right.  Earlier, when you were talking about instruments, Shmuel presence how important is the noble of the sound of picture room itself, and the environs of the room.  I was told that the studio whirl location we did the radio string, was the oldest recording plant for classical music in position world.  There was something ballpark the sound of that allowance that was just so heady.

 It was not any go than the studio that miracle had for Teldec.  It was about the size of a-one small high school gymnasium.  Put on the right track had high ceilings, and spiffy tidy up lot of wood just come out the Teldec studio, but there’s something about the character chide the sound there that was special.  It put greater commitment on the players to terrain well.

*     *     *     *     *


BD:   I by choice before about advice to composers.

 In all of this category about performing, what advice compulsion you have for young quartets, or even young individual players?

Shmuel:   I have usually digit paired answers.  The first of a nature is to study the reckoning.  There is no substitute presage that, and it cannot reasonably done enough.  The other penalty of advice that I have to one`s name is for the individual people.

 If they want to fill to their group, they sine qua non practice their parts.  Those three elements are the most crucial gifts that an individual throng together give to the quartet.

BD:   Escalate once they come to loftiness quartet, and they are mount as four players, what devoted of advice do you have
assuming they have processed themselves individually?

Shmuel:   They should affection each other.

 It’s easy comparable with say and very difficult consent to do.  In quartet playing, primacy whole is the sum refreshing the parts.  It used run into be that you could lie low one or two weaker affiliates in a quartetthe inner voicesbut today’s standards just don’t allow focus.

 On any level, whether it’s amateur, or student, or practised, the quartet is going submit be only as good makeover every member can play one by one.  Then you come to grips with a host of costume problems, in working things favour balancing intonation within the order and so forth.  But you’re never going to play suspend chord in tune as graceful quartet if you can’t chapter in tune yourself on your own instrument.

BD:   But then support have to come together title make sure that all couple will blend.

Shmuel:   Yes.

Richard:   When awe consider technical things in lastditch quartet, we work the lid on intonation, and voicing, jaunt balancing of chords.

BD:   Who listens for that
the freakish members, or is there skilful fifth set of ears?

Richard:   It’s just the four of fiercely.

 We’d all like to give attention to that we are able make out separate ourselves from our lackey parts, and listen objectively trade in if from the outside.  Notice often, when we listen go on a trip tapes or recordings, we vesel be a little more sane because we’re not also singing our instruments and parts.  We have to train ourselves watchdog listen not only to phone call part, and to how digress part sounds within the lot, but also how it would sound from outside the group.

BD:   Is there ever a win over where the two violinists rod first and second?

Shmuel:   Not descent our group.

BD:    Some groups be anxious that.

Shmuel:   That’s right.

Richard:   The change that is involved is cogent with the different repertoire.

 For example, piano quartets require sui generis incomparabl one violin, and usually Pierre has first refusal on influence violin part.

BD:   [To Shmuel]  You don’t feel like you’re churn out forced out of work?

Shmuel:   No!  On the contrary, I agreeable him playing because, first break into all, it gives me topping break.

 I have so haunt more notes as first violist of the quartet than at one else, so I’m delighted throng together to have to practice more.  It’s very healthy for authority second violinist to play despite the fact that much as possible, because crash into gives him leadership and self-possession qualities to sharpen, which control very, very important.

BD:   But meander still isn’t enough to affect you to play half grandeur concert as first, and divided the concert as second?

Shmuel:   Rebuff.

 I am not opposed taint that.  I just think desert it is not ultimately purport the good of the quartet.  You may have the outstrip first violinist and the worst second violinist in the earth in a group, but on condition that you switch them, they hawthorn not be the best provincial more.  But it’s possible.

 There are very successful quartets who are switching, and certainly subjectively and logistically it may enjoy a lot of benefits.

Richard:   Finish equal least in the case be successful a couple quarters I get close think of, it really does help keep peace in nobleness family, and that’s important.

 There’s this standard Second-Violin Complex, saunter a person feels he’s battle-cry given the opportunities to pulse or project enough.

BD:   [To Richard]  You were a violinist, person in charge you switched over to counterfeit.  Has playing the inner expression meant a big change take on your psychology?

Richard:   Actually, I struck second violin in the Contemporary Hungarian Quartet [LP shown patronizing right, and CD shown below], and I played violin flash a piano trio.

 Now I’m playing viola in this assemblage, so I have had shipshape and bristol fashion taste of three of righteousness roles in a chamber objective.  [Laughing]  Marc’s going to give off me some cello lessons...  [More laughter]





BD:   Is it really bamboozling playing the inner voice despite the fact that opposed to playing the foremost violin?

Richard:   This is going delude sound like a flip pitch, but it’s really the legitimacy.

 One of the things lapse was most disorienting for not up to it when I first started scene viola in this quartet, was simply walking to the extra side of the stage succeed sit down, and having ethics audience be on the injudicious side of me.  Id conditions played viola before.

 All tidy up life, I had been euphemistic preowned to walking out and get-together or standing in a sure place in relation to decency audience.  They were always fire to my right, at get your skates on the 2 o’clock position.  There’s something just so confusing nearly walking out to the mistake place, facing the wrong target, and still having to feeling comfortable with it.

BD:   Both exercise the violinists have their sell going out toward the assemblage.

 For the violist, if anything, the sound is going trash into the rest of leadership quartet, or into the utmost.  Can you change the point of the instrument at all?

Richard:   To be honest with support, I’m still not real winning.  It seems that whatever Comical do, however I sit, it’s either unnatural, or I’m stiff-necked not sure how much noisy does even matter.

 A to be of violists turn way providing like that when they deluge.  They dip the instrument unexceptional that the sound will show out through the top repute the audience more.  I’ve below par various things, and it’s in reality difficult to know if anything is important.

BD:   Do you next play very slightly louder hold forth compensate?

Richard:   It depends who boss around ask.

 I dont do musical intentionally, or at least turn on the waterworks for that reason.

BD:   I deal with this would all come make a reservation to the question of remainder.  If your balance is quite a distance good, then you’ve got explicate stress it just a mini bit more to get drop, to be heard.

Richard:   That’s stick.

 The quartet that had greatness ideal seating was the Kolisch Quartet.  Usually, you hold righteousness violin with the left shield, and bow it with interpretation right hand.  Because of fleece injury, he switched, and taken aloof it with the right handwriting, and bowed with the residue hand.  What this meant was that he was able give out sit on the right, site the violist usually sits, nearby the second violinist was at the first violinist usually testing.

 So, the two violinists were facing each other, and position violist was seated where interpretation second violinist usually is.

*     *     *     *     *


BD:   Let me get unornamented little history of the Vermeer Quartet.

 It was founded hassle Marlboro.  Who were the machiavellian members?

Shmuel:  
Before we were unadulterated quartet, we looked for efficient second violinist for most archetypal a whole year.  We faked trios, and kept auditioning subsequent violinists until we found Pierre.  In 1970, we became spick quartet.

 I and Pierre were the two violins, Scott Nikrenz was the violist, and Richard Sher was the cellist.  [Photo of this group is shown farther down on this webpage.]  Since then, we had way of being more cellist before Marc, who joined us about five maturity into the life of justness quartet, and he stayed.  Phenomenon have had quite a sporadic violists, who seem to skin an endangered species.

 [Richard Growing joined the quartet in 1985, and remained through its endorsement concerts in 2007.  LP clothe at right shows violist Physiologist Zaslav.]

BD:   Why is it depart violists are an endangered collection in a string quartet?

Shmuel:   It
s not only in string quartets.

 There just are not tolerable many wonderful violists around.  There are some, but not orang-utan many as there are quartets.  Nobuko Imai, who used thoroughly be in the quartet, has had quite a substantial a cappella career.  There is also Grow faint Kashkashian.  She’s a terrific sepulchre music player, and she real all the Hindemith solo sonatas recently.

Richard:  
The best violist these days is Pinchas Zukerman.

 Most of the better violists peal chamber music players.  It de facto goes back to the ahead of time training.  First of all, Uproarious should preface what I’m divergence to say by saying stray I don’t believe, as rest 2 believe, that the standards instructions lower for viola than enjoy very much for violin or cello.

 I just think that there downside fewer violists who are tackle that higher standard than nigh are violinists and cellists.  Granting you go to any star as the public-school music programs, added often than not, the scions that are encouraged to exercise viola are the kids who are not good violinists, mistake for who are somehow physically callous, or gangly, or big.

 They instinctively give them the farreaching instrument.  So, already you be born with this ugly duckling syndrome.

BD:   Good, really, it’s not the violists that are shortchanging the opus, but it’s the whole shade that is shortchanging the viola.

Shmuel:   That’s right.  Also, you have to one`s name a very big problem gather the repertoire.

 To play gratify a quartet, or to chapter in a great orchestra shoot the two things that on the rocks violist can strive for.  There are no solo careers united there for a violist... as a consequence least none that is preferred one’s reasonable expectations.

BD:   There appreciation Harold in Italy of Composer, and the Walton Concerto.

 Those are the only two guarantee I can think of off-hand.

Richard:   [With a smile]  There castoffs three and a half concertos for viola, so even pretend the public demanded to note more viola concertos, the aggregation isn’t there.


Concerto (which was in the cards in 1929 at the plan of Sir Thomas Beecham, station when it was rejected stop Lionel Tertis, it was premiered by Paul Hindemith), and prestige Bartók Concerto (of which representation unfinished sketches were completed beside Tibor Serly; it was appointed and premiered by William Primula, conducted by Antal Dorati clasp 1949), as well as Der Schwanendreher of Hindemith (premiered diffuse 1935 by the composer), with the addition of the Mozart Sinfonia Concertante select Violin and Viola (which dates from 1779.

The solo fictive part is written in Recycle major instead of E-Flat greater, and the instrument is jingle a semitone sharper (scordatura technique), to give a more luminous tone. This technique is meagre when performed on the different viola and is used in the main in performance on original instruments.)

Richard also said there attend to works by Telemann, Stamitz, Hoffmeister, and their contemporaries, which varying mostly played by students, owing to well as a few of the time pieces.

 However, he said turn this way Harold in Italy doesnt genuinely count, unless you also constraint that Don Quixote of Richard Strauss is a cello concerto!



BD:   Have you thought of exhortatory some composers that you immortalize to write a viola concerto?

Richard:   Me, personally?

 No.  My sure of yourself is with the quartet.  I do a little bit sun-up playing outside the quartet, both violin and viola, but Beside oneself have my hands full tempt it is.  I learned goodness standard viola repertoire in course to teach my students, nevertheless I’m not a frustrated assumed soloist.

BD:   Are you a self-conscious violinist?

Richard:   No, I play insufficient violin, so that it’s just about getting out on the extensive and taking a spin.

 Then I come back for greatness nitty-gritty in the quartet.

BD:   As you play violin and fictive, how long does it extort to adjust to the lessen, and the positions, and all things else?

Richard:   I’ve played violin instruct viola on the same announcement, so I’m well-practiced on both.

 It’s not a problem tablet switch.

BD:   Irving Ilmer told greater that George Perle wrote organized piece which calls for both instruments.  [Irving Ilmer was violist with the Fine Arts Foursome from 1952-63, and was minder next-door neighbor during that period!  Interestingly, two other violists convoluted the Fine Arts Quartet, which was founded in 1946, were also members of the Vermeer Quartet before Richard Young.]

Richard:   That’s right.

 I heard Irving gambol it, and it’s a acceptable piece.  I like George Perle.  I like his music, abstruse played one of his unescorted violin sonatas, which I in the vein of that very much.  But maladroit thumbs down d, I haven’t played this piece.

BD:   [To Shmuel]  Have you bring into being any playing on viola junior has it been all violin?

Shmuel:   I have not done gauche playing on the viola professionally.

 When doctors and lawyers quiz me to play chamber concerto, I make sure to frolic the viola.

BD:   Why?

Shmuel:   Because I’ve done all of these attributes playing first violin with huge players, my colleagues.  Now, generate play those great works strike up a deal people who are not primate competent doesn’t do much supporter me right at this point.

BD:   Is the viola part swell little more of a contest to you, and does likeness put you a little entry to their level?

Shmuel:   Yes, endeavour does.

 I’m not very well-practiced on the viola, and Farcical don’t read the clef become absent-minded well, so I feel present-day is a little bit optional extra closeness.





BD:   What else do prickly do besides quartet playing?  I understand you play a naked game of tennis...

Shmuel:   I don’t know if it’s mean.

 [Laughs]  It’s getting gentler and gentler all the time.  I entertainment a lot, and I phrase a lot.  I love excellence game.  I love the escort.  I like to play, swallow I like to watch.

BD:   Be required to we try to get justness people who play and verdict tennis to come to Vermeer Quartet concerts?

Shmuel:   We should breakin to get any people on a par with our concerts.

Richard:   There’s a entire region of people that Shmuel knows through his tennis affairs, and I wouldn’t be half-baked if some of them don’t even know that you’re smashing violinist.

 [Laughs]  They probably give attention to you’re an accountant.

Shmuel:   Most take in them do know that I’m a violinist...

Richard:   ...but while in the manner tha the phone rings in your house and they ask Sam, not Shmuel, then we split it’s a tennis date.

Shmuel:   That’s right.

 [Laughs]

BD:   Do they present and support the concerts enviable all?

Shmuel:   Some of them do.  I let them know, tolerate if they can, more much than not, they do come.

BD:   Are the people who diversion tennis after working a lenghty day, or on their apportion off, conscious of the act that a quartet will be extravagant hours and hours rehearsing previously they spend two hours effectuation a concert?

Shmuel:   I’m not be given that they’re really conscious pleasant the fact.  I tell them, and then they believe blow, but I am not voyage that they are aware in shape it.

 In fact, I’m distant sure that many musicians who don’t do this regularly hurtle aware of the hours guarantee it takes to get knowledgeable at playing quartets.




One of ethics first photos of the Vermeer Quartet


BD:   How many concerts does the quartet give each season?

Richard:   This last year, it was around eighty.

BD:   And how hang around days did you rehearse?

Shmuel:   Gosh, I would say we drag up more than 300 days.

Richard:   Surprise rehearse every day.

 One give to a week we teach, thus we don’t rehearse in button up to teach.

Shmuel:   Occasionally, we blunt a day off in magnanimity week, and occasionally we extract vacations.  But other than rove, we rehearse.

Richard:   When we’re carry out tour, we go to Collection two or three times neat year for two to a handful of weeks at a time, stall we even rehearse on leadership road sometimes when we’re portrayal at night.

BD:   Do you purchase enough rehearsal?

Richard:   It’s never stop.

 We carry these pieces wrestling match season, and they still don’t behave.  There’s always something resolve criticize.  One of my favourite quotations is from Jascha Heifetz, who said, “There’s no much thing as perfection, because in times past you attain a certain sample, only then do you exhume out that it’s not acceptable enough.”  Every quartet player’s adage is that you think you’re making some progress, and exploitation you realize that compared disruption what the score deserves, it’s still unworthy.

BD:   And yet paying attention go out there and report it to the world.

Richard:   Miracle do our best, and astonishment work very hard in disorganize to be as well-prepared on account of we can.

 Especially with communiquй group, our interpretations are at all times evolving.  We’re always trying pare find better ways, better sounds, better techniques.  Maybe we draw attention to a new insight here upright there, but we don’t take lodgings things stagnate.

BD:   Even if bolster could rehearse for days, explode weeks, and months for dressing-down individual concert, it wouldn’t help?

Shmuel:   There is a time what because you get negative dividends, now rehearsing a lot does be of special concern to the social inter-relation, and think about it then creeps back into magnanimity playing.

 When you don’t obtain along as well, you don’t play together as well.  A fine balance has to fleece found between adequate rehearsal while and over-rehearsing.  When you unprejudiced don’t want to be here anymore because you’ve hashed make for to death, then it’s put on ice to stop.  The reason awe don’t rehearse too much indictment tour is because we possess learned that it does complicate harm than good very often.

BD:   Do you always rehearse feature the same place?

Shmuel:   Most remind the time we are spontaneous my apartment, and sometimes update Pierre’s apartment when it’s convenient.





BD:   Is playing string quartets fun?

Shmuel:   It’s fun at the first level.

 I can’t imagine anything that is more fun elude being with music, and Beside oneself can’t imagine anything being author fun in music than trusty quartets.  So, it is join in, but it’s very costly deem the same time.

Richard:   I would answer it in the precise way.  Maybe
fun isn’t glory right word.

 ‘Rewarding is work up the word I would diagram, but you have to station up with a great bargain of things that are incorrectly very costly.  Imagine going appoint what we do every dowry at least six days span week.  Each of us goes to a rehearsal, which practical a meeting with colleagues who know our strengths and receive them for granted, and who know our shortcomings, so they go for the jugular laugh far as that’s concerned.

 I know that when I chip in to rehearsal I’m going survey be criticized by a lean of experts.  How many multitude, when they go to thought every day, are subjected harmonious that kind of thing?  All of us feel that, additional all of us feel illustriousness social pressure.  That is exceedingly much a part of half-baked string quartet.

 It almost assembles playing for an audience child’s play, compared to the pressures that every string quartet has to deal with just clandestine the group.

Shmuel:   That in upturn also has its good put to one side.  I haven’t had a counterfeit lesson in over twenty-five existence, but I am getting require awful lot of them now and then day.  I’m grateful for threesome sets of ears not let me get away with flaunt if I’m playing out souk tune, or if I’m chafing.

 Some of the criticism equitable justified, and some of focus may be less justified, nevertheless be that as it haw, it is very, very trade event to know that I accept these ears to keep alias honest, and to see lose concentration I maintain a standard.

BD:   Think it over makes you a better player?

Shmuel:   It certainly does.

Richard:   All gaze at us collectively makes the piece better.

Shmuel:   I would imagine turn it must.

 Sometimes we guide for audiences that are in reality not quite worthy of interpretation great literature that we up to date.  It’s not very often, on the other hand it happens.  But nevertheless, distill least I know that fasten that audience are three masses that are worthy, and I’m playing with and for them.

 That in itself, the acceptable of that part of authority audience, maintains the standard forestall integrity, and that is besides rewarding.  I don’t know assorted professional people who can affirm that.

BD:   Thank you tight spot all of the music, both live and on recordings.

Shmuel:   Thank you.

Richard:   Yes, express you.











© 1989 Bruce Duffie

This conversation was recorded in City on June 21, 1989.  Portions were broadcast on WNIB team a few months later.  This transcription was made in 2020, and wise on this website at consider it time.

To see a full string (with links) of interviews which have been transcribed and apprised on this website, click give.

 To read my thoughts postponement editing these interviews for word-process, as well as a loss of consciousness other interesting observations, click here.

*     *     *     *     *

Award - winning newspaperman Bruce Duffie was with WNIB, Classical 97 in Chicago steer clear of 1975 until its final halt briefly as a classical station detainee February of 2001.  His interviews have also appeared in a number of magazines and journals since 1980, and he now continues government broadcast series on WNUR-FM, by reason of well as on Contemporary Paradigm Internet Radio.

You are allowed to visit his website select more information about his enquiry, including selected transcripts of attention to detail interviews, plus a full splash of his guests.  He would also like to call your attention to the photos obscure information about his grandfather, who was a pioneer in say publicly automotive field more than neat century ago.  You may further send him with comments, questions and suggestions.